Posts on Feeds & RSS – is it really time to say good bye?

Technorati Tags: ,,

Alone Among the Crowd

 

TechCrunch blogger MG Seigler recently blogged on Google Reader:  “Google-reader-still-trying-to-figure-out-this-whole-social-thing-still-failing

I use Google Reader, but not as a social platform, purely as the back-end service that collects feeds that I subscribe to, and connects to various end-points I use to access the feeds.  In fact I don’t even use it as a the UI presentation layer to read the feeds.  For the web front-end I use Feedly as I’ve blogged here previously : – Blog post about Feedly  For my mobile interface I use Viigo, and therefore Google Reader provides the sync and glue between my primary end-points.

Again the author’s point about the lack of social features, isn’t incorrect. But the primarily function of ‘feed reader’ is to provide a good feed and feed management interface; not to become a social networking tool.

I just wonder if that is truly the direction that Google wants to take the product?  Not that the sharing isn’t valuable, but I think Google will want to be the primary RSS reader/aggregation service 1st and foremost because that will be of closest affinity to its search products – i.e. why they bought Feedburner.  Google will also be well aware of competitor social & real time products that do the ‘social’ part much more effectively; if they bought Feedburner, it makes sense they will acquire what they need when they think it’s time to do so.

Game Over Man! Game Over

This was followed up by another TechCrunch blogger Steve Gilmour blogging on the demise of RSS :  “Rest-in-peace-RSS“.  I think he’s over egging the cake here.

Fair point in the world of real time, RSS is a not in the race.  But that’s a function of search and speed not what RSS was designed or to meant to do.

However, it’s definitely not the time to  switch it off/or turn away from it completely.  Perhaps in Steve’s case it no longer satisfies the ‘speed and delivery’ stakes in comparison to  Twitter and the rest of the cohorts on the social media wave. But Steve’s role is out there at the very edge of it all and he needs his tools to stay in that position.

I think for most ‘ordinary Joe’s’ the eclipse of RSS by Twitter and real time search services is not a reason to move away from RSS, but rather to decide on what tools or functions provides a useful balance of both going forward.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s